Skip to content

How To Make Buttermilk Yogurt (8 Easy Methods)

How To Make Buttermilk Yogurt

A tasty and healthful substitute for conventional yogurt is buttermilk yogurt. Making yogurt at home is becoming more and more popular because it’s affordable, tastes great, and has several health advantages. This article will go over the advantages of creating How To Make Buttermilk Yogurt at home, what you’ll need, how to prepare it, how to choose the best ingredients, what equipment you’ll need, how to make it step-by-step, how to flavor it, how to store and preserve it, how to present it creatively, how to compare homemade and store-bought versions, health advice, and business opportunities.

Benefits of Making Buttermilk Yogurt at Home

Making your buttermilk yogurt comes with a myriad of advantages. Not only does it contribute to your health, but it also allows for cost-effective customization of flavors to suit your taste buds. Let’s delve into these benefits and discover why more people are turning to homemade yogurt.


  1. Milk: Start with 4 cups of whole milk. Whole milk is preferred for its higher fat content, which contributes to a creamier yogurt texture.
  2. Buttermilk Starter: 2 tablespoons of buttermilk with live active cultures. Ensure it is plain and free from any additives or preservatives.
  3. Equipment:
    • A saucepan
    • A thermometer
    • A whisk
    • A clean kitchen towel or cheesecloth
    • A mixing bowl
    • A yogurt maker or an insulated container with a lid
    • Jars or containers for storing the finished yogurt

Step-by-step Process How To Make Buttermilk Yogurt

Yogurt is a versatile and nutritious dairy product that can be enjoyed on its own or used as an ingredient in various dishes. How To Make Buttermilk Yogurt at home not only allows you to control the ingredients but also ensures a fresh and delicious end product. In this step-by-step guide, we will explore how to make buttermilk yogurt – a creamy and tangy variation that adds a unique twist to the traditional yogurt-making process.

Step 1: Preparing the Milk

Pour 4 cups of whole milk into a saucepan. Heat the milk slowly over medium heat, using a thermometer to monitor the temperature. Heat the milk until it reaches about 180°F (82°C). This step helps to denature the proteins in the milk, promoting a thicker yogurt texture.

Step 2: Cooling the Milk

Allow the milk to cool down to around 110°F (43°C). This is the ideal temperature for the live cultures in the buttermilk to thrive and ferment the milk into yogurt. Use a whisk to stir occasionally during the cooling process to prevent skin from forming on the surface.

Step 3: Adding the Buttermilk Starter

Once the milk has cooled to the desired temperature, add 2 tablespoons of buttermilk with live active cultures to the milk. Whisk the mixture gently to ensure an even distribution of the starter throughout the milk.

Adding the Buttermilk Starter

Step 4: Incubating the Mixture

Transfer the milk and buttermilk mixture to a clean container or a yogurt maker. If using a yogurt maker, follow the manufacturer’s instructions for incubation. If using an insulated container, cover it with a lid and wrap it in a clean kitchen towel to maintain a stable temperature.

Allow the mixture to incubate for about 6 to 8 hours. During this time, the live cultures will convert the milk into yogurt, developing its characteristic thickness and tangy flavor. The longer the incubation, the thicker and tangier the yogurt will become.

How To Make Buttermilk Yogurt

Step 5: Checking for Doneness

After the incubation period, check the yogurt for doneness. It should have a firm texture and a slightly tangy taste. If it seems too runny, you can let it incubate for a few more hours.

Step 6: Cooling and Refrigerating

Once the yogurt is ready, carefully remove it from the incubator. Place it in the refrigerator to cool for at least 2 hours. Cooling helps to set the yogurt further and enhance its texture.

Step 7: Straining (Optional)

For an even thicker yogurt consistency, you can strain the yogurt by placing a clean cheesecloth or kitchen towel over a bowl and pouring the yogurt onto it. Allow it to drain for a few hours in the refrigerator. The liquid that drains off is known as whey, and the remaining yogurt will be a rich, creamy Greek-style yogurt.

Step 8: Enjoying Your Buttermilk Yogurt

Once the yogurt has cooled and, if desired, been strained, transfer it to jars or containers for storage. Your homemade buttermilk yogurt is now ready to be enjoyed! You can savor it on its own, mix it with fresh fruits, honey, or granola, or use it as a base for various recipes.

Tips and Troubleshooting:

  1. Starter Quality: Ensure the buttermilk used as a starter contains live active cultures. This is crucial for the fermentation process.
  2. Consistent Temperature: Maintaining a consistent incubation temperature is vital for successful yogurt making. Use a thermometer to monitor and adjust as needed.
  3. Incubation Time: Adjust the incubation time based on your preference for yogurt thickness and tanginess. Longer incubation results in a thicker and more tangy yogurt.
  4. Yogurt Maker vs. Insulated Container: While a yogurt maker provides a controlled environment, an insulated container can be just as effective. The key is to maintain a stable temperature during incubation.
  5. Experiment with Straining: Straining the yogurt is optional and depends on personal preference. Experiment with different straining times to achieve the desired thickness.


In conclusion, making buttermilk yogurt at home is a rewarding and enjoyable endeavor. With its numerous benefits, creative possibilities, and business potential, there’s no reason not to try crafting your batch of delicious and healthy buttermilk yogurt.

What Are Some Common Mistakes When Making Buttermilk Yogurt?

Making buttermilk yogurt at home is a rewarding process, but it comes with its share of challenges. Here are some common mistakes to watch out for:

1. Overheating the Milk:

Issue: Heating the milk above 180°F (82°C).

Solution: Monitor the temperature closely; overheating can lead to grainy or curdled yogurt.

2. Inconsistent Incubation Temperature:

Issue: Fluctuations in temperature during incubation.

Solution: Use a reliable thermometer and consider investing in a yogurt maker for a controlled environment.

3. Insufficient Incubation Time:

Issue: Rushing the incubation process.

Solution: Follow the recommended 6 to 8 hours for optimal thickness and flavor.

4. Neglecting Starter Quality:

Issue: Using outdated or poor-quality buttermilk.

Solution: Choose a high-quality, plain buttermilk with live cultures and check the expiration date.

5. Straining Mishaps:

Issue: Over-straining, resulting in excessively thick yogurt.

Solution: Experiment with straining times to achieve the desired balance.

What Are Some Recipes That Use Buttermilk Yogurt?

Buttermilk yogurt’s versatility extends beyond a simple snack. Here are two delightful recipes to try:

Buttermilk Yogurt Parfait

  • Ingredients:
    • Buttermilk yogurt
    • Fresh berries
    • Granola
    • Honey
  • Instructions:
    1. Layer buttermilk yogurt in a glass.
    2. Add fresh berries, and granola, and drizzle honey.
    3. Repeat layers for a delightful and nutritious parfait.

Buttermilk Yogurt Smoothie

  • Ingredients:
    • Buttermilk yogurt
    • Banana
    • Spinach leaves
    • Almond milk
    • Chia seeds
  • Instructions:
    1. Blend all ingredients until smooth.
    2. Pour into a glass and sprinkle chia seeds for added nutrition.

Can I Make This With Non-Dairy Milk?

you can make buttermilk yogurt using non-dairy milk. Follow these steps:

  1. Selecting Non-Dairy Milk:
    • Choose a higher-fat non-dairy milk for creaminess.
    • Unsweetened varieties work best.
  2. Adjusting Temperature:
    • Heat non-dairy milk to 180°F (82°C), then cool to 110°F (43°C).
  3. Choosing a Compatible Starter:
    • Ensure the non-dairy milk is compatible with live cultures.
  4. Follow Standard Incubation:
    • Monitor consistency and adjust incubation time based on preferences.

How Do I Know If The Yogurt Is Fermented Enough?

Determining the right fermentation level is crucial:

  • Texture Check:
    • The yogurt should be firm and slightly gel-like.
  • Tanginess:
    • Taste a spoonful to assess tanginess; adjust based on preference.
  • Curled Edges:
    • Curled edges around the container indicate successful fermentation.
  • Whey Separation:
    • Some separation is normal; excessive liquid may indicate over-fermentation.


Can I use any type of milk for making buttermilk yogurt?

but certain types may yield better results. Experiment with different milk varieties to find your preferred taste and texture.

How long does the fermentation process take?

The fermentation time can vary but generally takes between 6 to 12 hours. Keep an eye on the consistency and flavor to determine when it’s ready.

Can I freeze homemade buttermilk yogurt?

Freezing is possible, but it may alter the texture. It’s recommended to consume fresh for the best taste and consistency.

What are the health benefits of buttermilk yogurt?

Buttermilk yogurt is rich in probiotics, promoting gut health, and is a good source of essential nutrients like calcium and protein.

Is making buttermilk yogurt cost-effective compared to buying it from the store?

Making buttermilk yogurt at home is not only cost-effective but also allows you to customize flavors according to your preferences.